“Once” = comfort food

In this 9.29 L.A. Times essay, critic Kenneth Turan seems to be writing about Once from a slightly different angle — i.e., how come it took so long for this exquisite little film to get picked up? — than the one I went with yesterday, which was basically “how come more Average Joes haven’t paid to see it?” But he gets around to saying the exact same thing at the conclusion.

“The Once experience worried me,” Turan writes, “because it underlined how much the risk-averse studio mindset of being indifferent to quality, of caring more about what can be sold than what will be cherished, is infecting an arena that has always prided itself on being impervious to those ways of thinking.
“Yet to be fair, it would be wrong to completely blame the specialty distributors for their lack of brio where acquiring Once was concerned. If they are timid, if they lack trust in the willingness of an audience to find and support something that lacks marketable elements, it’s because experience has shown them that they have reason to be afraid.
“Even now, in the face of the success and visibility of Once, I am constantly running into supporters of independent cinema who have not gone to see the film partly because, despite a terrific Fox Searchlight campaign, it lacks the kind of easy-to-remember hook having Keri Russell in a cute uniform has given Waitress.”

Turan’s kicker graph is well phrased, but it’s a stern lecture from a man who’s losing his patience with those who say theyr’e into offbeat cuisine but in fact are dilletantes looking for comfort food: “If you want distributors to acquire films as sophisticated and unusual as Once, ” Turan admonishes, “you must make the extra effort to seek them out and patronize them. If you don’t, don’t count on them to be around when you need them the most.”
The irony is that Once is about as comfort food-y as anyone could ask for. It just happens to be very Irish and low-budgety and lacking in big stars.

31 thoughts on ““Once” = comfort food

  1. For a film like this to make big money, Long Island soccer moms have to be lining up the way they did for THE BIG MONTY. They didn’t.

  2. This small film with no budget ($150,000)–a movie that looks like a foreign language film–has already grossed over $6 million domestic. That’s huge. There are tons of indie films this size that would be thrilled to gross over a million.
    By the way, I didn’t like the music and found it quite boring.

  3. we’ve been yelling about this for the last 15 years as the Dependies took over for the Indies. It took him this long to see the light?
    Daring indie died when Harvey passed on In the Company of Men because he imagine being able to market the film

  4. should have written “becuase he couldn’t imagine how to market the film” when talking about Harvey and In the Company of Men.

  5. It was also difficult to take possession of the film, but that’s a different story — one for the indie annals. But I want to point this out:
    Larry, “you’re gorgeous.”
    “You’re goregeous” Larry.
    Larry is “gorgeous.”
    “Gorgeous Larry.”
    “Larry the Georgeous.”

  6. best. movie. of. the. year. so. far.
    at least, it’s in the discussion, along with Zodiac and Ratatouille.

  7. It’s no Little Miss Sunshine, but it seems to be doing pretty well for itself. I wonder if it’s doing well enough that the distributor doesn’t regret picking it up though. If it fortifies the timid attitudes Turan talks about, then that’s no good.
    I’ll bet a lot of people discover it on DVD.

  8. I was talking to a soccer mom yesterday and she asked me about ONCE … she asked “Am I going to be able to understand what they are saying?”

  9. For a film like this to make big money, Long Island soccer moms have to be lining up the way they did for THE BIG MONTY. They didn’t.

  10. Clearly I’m in the minority, but I don’t consider it a crime against humanity that people are skipping “Once.” I would only recommend it to people who are really into folk music.

  11. #1- the Title “Once” sucks
    #2- the trailer sucks
    #3- the unknown actors sucks
    #4 – the music (what I heard) sucks
    I haven’t seen the movie, I passed on free screening because it looked like a straight to video. I would recommend that this type of movie stay overseas and in Great Britain, build up momentum to a fever pitch and then bring it overseas to the U.S. Or better yet – why not turn it into a Broadway musical and then make it a film?

  12. there is no rule that says you have to like ONCE or the music in the film … I like Once because this is a film whose spine says that there are first loves and true loves and that they are never the same …

  13. “I was talking to a soccer mom yesterday and she asked me about ONCE … she asked ‘Am I going to be able to understand what they are saying?’”
    The bitch about that question is that even if “Once” were subtitled to assist with the thicker Irish accents, so many people would then retort, “oh – I can’t stand subtitles”.
    To each their own, but I can usually enjoy a movie just fine even if there are some lines I can’t catch right. I don’t understand each and every lyric in a lot of songs I like either but I enjoy them all the same; and the human mind has a way of filling in the gaps without much of a hassle.

  14. It’s no Little Miss Sunshine, but it seems to be doing pretty well for itself. I wonder if it’s doing well enough that the distributor doesn’t regret picking it up though. If it fortifies the timid attitudes Turan talks about, then that’s no good.

    I’ll bet a lot of people discover it on DVD.

  15. “#1- the Title “Once” sucks
    #2- the trailer sucks
    #3- the unknown actors sucks
    #4 – the music (what I heard) sucks
    I haven’t seen the movie, I passed on free screening because it looked like a straight to video. I would recommend that this type of movie stay overseas and in Great Britain, build up momentum to a fever pitch and then bring it overseas to the U.S. Or better yet – why not turn it into a Broadway musical and then make it a film?
    Posted by: Chicago48 at July 29, 2007 07:42 PM”
    The Anti-Christ has appeared. Or is it the Devil himself? Sweet, sweet Rapture.

  16. Re the long summer of Fox Searchlight:
    Isn’t it interesting that they’re trying to sell SUNSHINE (by print ads)as if it’s the twin of the Soderbergh/Cameron/Clooney SOLARIS remake?

  17. At least the last of the 50s-60s arthouse giants. Amazing to think of how somebody like him made one significant film after another, deeply personal, devoid of commercial elements (okay, sex had something to do with it, but still)– and an audience came out for it, film after film, just to see what he’d do next.
    I felt like his reputation had sagged in recent years; prepare for it to start rising again.
    If you’ve never seen his work, go watch Wild Strawberries, then watch Persona.

  18. Does anyone know what in living fuck T.Holly is talking about (here, or ever)? I’m not asking T.Holly directly because when people have done this in the past they usually get an equally obtuse response. All of his/her comments seem to belong in a thread I’ve never heard, or are responding to other comments no one actually made, and are basically one step up from unreadable.
    Anyway. I think it’s worth mentioning that loving the music in ONCE doesn’t seem necessary to loving the movie, at least not for me. I saw the movie twice and I have the soundtrack, but most of the songs are a lot better in the context of the movie; there are only a handful I really listen to very often. I guess if you found the music really dull you might get annoyed at the movie, but I found watching the characters make that music to be interesting enough on its own. The stripped-down, yearning (some might say a little whiny-sounding) stuff works for the film’s sweet, small story.
    And I do consider it a musical, not just a drama with music. I can’t look at the scene of the woman walking down the street at night with her headphones on as anything but a great (albeit small and not overblown in the usual way) musical number.

  19. Um. Where is this visibility that “Once” is getting? If it weren’t for the fact that I see the ads on this site, and that I read a review on HTF, I wouldn’t have known about this film at all. Maybe it is because I’m a parent and I don’t get out to the movie theater all that often anymore, but I’ve seen almost no marketing and I still haven’t watched the trailer. It also hasn’t gotten that much buzz on the sites that I read.
    While I wouldn’t expect it to get marketed like Transformers, but the lack of advertising really keeps people from knowing about it.

  20. I will watch Once because of all the hype on this site, but everything being said about it makes it sound unspeakably awful, and the trailer looks horrendous. Just wanted to point that out since that might have something to do with it not getting larger numbers. Anyway, will try to keep an open mind.

  21. Once has good character development, great scenery, is a very cinematic musical (per jesse) and is spoken with a bit of a beautiful and extremely understandable lilt (think “mudder”).
    On top of all that, it’s played with Irish jovialness, which as far as I can tell is a lot like American, not British, humor. “You’re gorgeous,” from the thriftshopkeeper to Hansard’s character, is one example. When I say the line in character to people, they rise above everything and laugh.
    One last thing. “The Hill” is the name of the song Marketa’s character sings at the piano while on break at the recording studio. The recorded version with strings doesn’t do it justice. When the DVD comes out, I’m sure the scene will make it to YouTube because it’s so powerful in the movie. The second time I saw it, I listened to the audience and heard gasps from several people around me when her character abruptly ends the song in tears.
    Anyway, it’s a great movie for anyone. You don’t have to be in a relationship, or want one, or be any particular sex, or be sexy or beautiful or play an instrument.

  22. At least the last of the 50s-60s arthouse giants. Amazing to think of how somebody like him made one significant film after another, deeply personal, devoid of commercial elements (okay, sex had something to do with it, but still)– and an audience came out for it, film after film, just to see what he’d do next.

    I felt like his reputation had sagged in recent years; prepare for it to start rising again.

    If you’ve never seen his work, go watch Wild Strawberries, then watch Persona.

  23. I’ve found that when I’m watching movies where the characters have thick accents it takes me about 5 minutes or so for my brain to adjust. Then I’m fine.
    Michael Bay is attached to the remake–when the guy on the street corner gets his money stolen, his guitar changes into a robot. A robot!

  24. It’s a “gorgeous” little movie, a gem, with an ending that just sneaks right up on you. Just when you’re thinking you know how this is gonna go, it chooses to go down a surprisingly touching and satisfying path. It doesn’t matter that you can’t understand the thick accents sometimes, the gist is all there if you aren’t a complete lughead.

  25. s+infirmier”>preparation+oral+concours+infirmier
    question+piege+oral+concours
    reussir+question+oral+concours
    sujet+corrige+oral+concours
    sujets+concours+oral+aide+soignante
    sujets+oral+concours+categorie
    teens+oral+blonde
    blonde+oral
    blonde+oral+sex
    oral+capes+interne+math
    lecon+d+oral+de+capes+de+math
    math+capes+oral
    oral+du+capes+intene+de+math
    oral+math+capes
    sujet+oral+capes+interne+math
    capes+interne+math+oral
    forum+oral+capes+math+2005
    programme+oral+capes+interne+math
    braun+oral+b
    brosse+a+dents+oral+b+braun
    braun+oral+b+3d
    brosse+a+dent+braun+oral+b
    braun+oral+b+7000
    braun+oral+b+oc+17
    braun+oral+b+professionnal+care+7000
    brossette+braun+oral+b
    oral+b+braun+oc+17+oxyjet
    braun+oral+b+plack+control+ultra
    braun+oral+b+professional+care
    oral+b+7000+braun
    oral+b+braun+professional+care
    jet+dentaire+braun+oral+b+water+md15a
    braun+brosse+dent+oral+b
    braun+oral+b+brosse+a+dents
    brosse+dent+braun+oral+b+sonic
    notice+braun+oral+b
    oral+b+braun+7000
    oral+and+b+and+braun
    oral+b+braun+3d
    oral+b+braun+8500+dlx
    braun+oral+b+3d+d15525
    braun+oral+b+3d+solo+15.511+brosse+e0+dent
    braun+oral+b+7500+oxyjet
    braun+oral+b+oc+18545
    braun+oral+b
    oral+b+braun
    brosse+a+dents+oral+b+braun
    braun+oral+b+3d
    brosse+a+dent+braun+oral+b
    oral+braun
    braun+oral+b+7000
    braun+oral+b+oc+17
    brosse+dent+braun+oral
    braun+oral+b+professionnal+care+7000
    oral+braun+d17511
    brossette+braun+oral+b
    oral+b+braun+oc+17+oxyjet
    braun+oral+b+plack+control+ultra
    braun+oral+b+professional+care
    oral+b+7000+braun
    oral+b+braun+professional+care
    brosse+dent+electrique+braun+oral+b
    jet+dentaire+braun+oral+b+water+md15a
    braun+brosse+dent+oral+b
    brosse+e0+dent+braun+oral+b
    braun+oral+b+brosse+a+dents
    brosse+dent+braun+oral+b+sonic
    notice+braun+oral+b
    oral+b+braun+7000
    oral+and+b+and+braun
    oral+b+braun+3d
    oral+b+braun+8500+dlx
    oral+b++braun+oc+17+oxyjet
    braun+oral+b+3d+d15525
    braun+oral+b+3d+solo+15.511+brosse+e0+dent
    braun+oral+b+7500+oxyjet
    braun+oral+b+oc+18545
    bail+fermage+oral
    bail+and+fermage+and+oral
    cassation+resiliation+bail+oral
    attestation+bail+fermage+oral
    oral+concours+aide+soignante
    sujet+d+oral+concours+aide+soignante
    concours+d+aide+soignante+l+oral
    sujets+oral+concours+aide+soignante
    sujets+concours+oral+aide+soignante
    anal+oral
    anal+oral+sex
    anal+and+aide+and+soignant+and+oral
    anal+and+oral+sex
    stade+oral+et+anal
    le+grand+oral+du+crfpa
    crfpa+grand+oral
    annale+grand+oral+crfpa
    descf+grand+oral
    grand+oral+descf
    grand+oral+iep
    grand+oral+iep+sujet
    fle+grand+debutant+oral
    grand+oral+inspection+generale
    facial+oral+porn+movie
    oral+du+bac+de+francais
    bac+oral+francais
    bac+oral+francais+corrige+video
    revision+oral+bac+francais
    bac+oral+francais+premiere
    l+oral+de+francais+au+bac
    sujets+corrige+oral+francais+bac
    bac+oral+francais+fiche
    sujet+oral+bac+francais
    oral+bac+francais+ruy+blas
    oral+francais+bac+exemple
    stage+oral+bac+francais
    date+oral+bac+francais+2006
    question+bac+oral+francais
    bac+francais+oral+comment+faire
    bac+francais+oral+date
    date+de+l+oral+du+bac+de+francais
    preparer+oral+bac+francais
    tricher+bac+blanc+oral+francais
    oral+bac+francais+entretien
    texte+bac+oral+francais
    little+oral+annie
    annale+oral+concours+infirmiere+puericultrice
    concours+infirmiere+oral
    hiv+and+transmission+and+oral+sex+and+not+oral+ulcers
    hiv+and+transmission+and+oral+sex+and+not+resource
    oral+amateur
    busty+amateur+boob+oral
    amateur+oral+teen
    oral+cumshot+amateur
    amateur+oral+cumshot
    amateur+oral+group
    amateur+oral+sex
    free+amateur+oral+sex
    forced+oral
    forced+to+oral
    brosse+a+dent+braun+oral+b
    braun+brosse+dent+oral+b
    braun+oral+b+brosse+a+dents
    spy+shower+girl
    girls+shower+spy
    shower+man
    man+in+shower
    man+pool+shower
    man+under+shower
    shower+room+man
    shower+boy
    teen+boy+shower
    frat+shower+boy
    boy+shower+spycam
    shower+masturbation
    girl+masturbation+shower
    shower+amateur+masturbation
    masturbation+girl+shower
    blond+masturbation+shower
    shower+masturbation+girl
    pussy+shower
    pussy+in+shower
    shower+hairy+pussy
    spy+shower
    spy+cam+shower
    spy+shower+girl
    girls+shower+spy
    outdoor+golden+shower
    2+teens+shower
    flower+squirt+shower+2
    baby+shower+gifts
    masturbation+shower
    girl+masturbation+shower
    shower+amateur+masturbation
    masturbation+girl+shower
    blond+masturbation+shower
    shower+masturbation+girl
    shower+public
    amateur+shower
    cum+shower+amateur
    shower+amateur+masturbation
    amateur+shower+gay
    shower+spycam
    boy+shower+spycam
    hidden+spycam+shower
    spycam+in+shower+video
    april+27s+shower
    fucking+shower
    fucking+mature+shower
    shower+fucking+men
    shower+lesbians
    shower+teen+lesbians
    lesbians+in+the+shower
    shower+male
    shower+nude+male
    teen+male+shower
    shower+young+woman
    shower+young
    young+boys+shower
    guys+in+shower
    guys+in+shower+room
    shower+room+guys
    shower+guys
    country+style+shower+curtains
    shower+couple
    couple+bridal+shower+invitation+wording
    shower+couple+teen
    couple+shower+invitation+wording
    lesbian+couple+shower
    shower+pregnant
    sexy+shower
    babe+lounge.com+galerie+sexy+shower
    huge+tits+shower
    big+tits+cum+shower
    shower+school
    high+school+shower
    http://search.jubii.dk/c
    gi-bin/pursuit?cat=loc&query=site:tagebuch.aol.de+invitation+wording+baby+shower
    third+baby+shower+invitation+wording
    free+baby+shower+invitation+wording+ideas
    example+baby+shower+invitation+wording
    ducky+baby+shower+invitation
    wording+for+baby+shower+invitation
    free+baby+shower+invitation+wording
    baby+shower+wording+invitation
    baby+shower+invitation+ideas
    baby+shower+invitation+wording
    free+baby+shower+invitation+ideas
    baby+shower+invitation+wording+ideas
    shower+fucking
    fucking+mature+shower
    shower+fucking+men
    gorgeous+masturbating+shower
    masturbating+gorgeous+shower
    golf+bathroom+shower+curtains
    bathroom+shower+curtains+and+accessories
    bathroom+windows+shower+curtains
    bathroom+lighthouse+shower+curtains
    bathroom+accessories+shower+curtains
    bathroom+accessories+and+shower+curtains
    matching+bathroom+curtains+shower+curtains
    windows+and+shower+curtains+for+bathroom
    bathroom+rugs+and+shower+curtains
    bathroom+towels+shower+curtains
    modern+bathroom+shower+curtains
    bathroom+shower+curtains
    bright+colored+bathroom+shower+curtains
    cum+shower
    gay+cum+shower
    cum+face+shower
    cum+shower+amateur
    cum+shower+gay
    big+tits+cum+shower
    big+boob+cum+shower
    bath
    bath+hotel
    bath+site+touristique
    bath+shopping
    bath+restaurant
    bath+divertissement
    cum+bath
    bath+salt
    bath+tub
    bukkake+bath
    bath+accessories
    salt+bath
    location+voiture+bath
    bath+salts
    bath+sex
    salts+bath
    sex+bath
    lesbian+bath
    caunos+mud+bath+tours
    gay+bath
    family+bath
    vacances+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    immobilier+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    repassage+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    location+voiture+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    week+end+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    traiteur+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    garde+meuble+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    vacances+bath
    demenagement+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    week+end+bath
    rencontre+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    livraison+domicile+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    location+maison+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    bird+bath
    livraison+fleurs+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    nude+bath
    location+bureau+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    bath+girl
    boy+bath
    restaurant+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    teen+bath
    vol+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    travel+bath
    mature+bath
    bath+rugby
    girl+bath
    location+bureau+bath
    bath+time
    bath+boy
    traiteur+bath
    livraison+domicile+bath
    vol+bath
    garde+meuble+bath
    bath+teen
    restaurant+a+bath
    repassage+bath
    baby+bath
    rencontre+bath
    boys+bath
    demenagement+bath
    bath+fuck
    bath+spa
    hotel+bath
    bath+cum
    clawfoot+bath+tubs
    bath+boys
    pee+bath
    bath+young
    bath+girls
    sperm+bath
    naked+bath
    bath+party
    fucking+bath
    bath+fucking
    first+bath
    as+bath
    bath+body+imagine+love+perfume+works
    bath+beauty
    shemale+bath
    bath+mature
    bath+robe
    biarritz+bath
    bath+gift+sets
    dog+bath
    steam+bath
    bath+duck
    fuck+bath
    spy+bath
    bath+accesories
    young+bath
    asian+bath
    bath+spy
    bath+apercu
    bath+big
    bath+gay
    bed+bath+and+beyond
    mud+bath
    bath+pump+room+restaurant
    textile+for+bath
    bath+hotel
    bath+site+touristique
    bath+shopping
    bath+restaurant
    bath+divertissement
    cum+bath
    bath+salt
    bath+tub
    bukkake+bath
    bath+accessories
    salt+bath
    location+voiture+bath
    bath+salts
    bath+sex
    salts+bath
    sex+bath
    lesbian+bath
    caunos+mud+bath+tours
    gay+bath
    family+bath
    vacances+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    immobilier+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    repassage+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    location+voiture+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    week+end+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    traiteur+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    garde+meuble+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    vacances+bath
    demenagement+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    week+end+bath
    rencontre+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    livraison+domicile+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    location+maison+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    bird+bath
    livraison+fleurs+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    nude+bath
    location+bureau+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    bath+girl
    boy+bath
    restaurant+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    teen+bath
    vol+bath+and+north+east+somerset
    travel+bath
    mature+bath
    bath+rugby
    girl+bath
    location+bureau+bath
    bath+time
    bath+boy
    traiteur+bath
    livraison+domicile+bath
    vol+bath
    garde+meuble+bath
    bath+teen
    restaurant+a+bath
    repassage+bath
    baby+bath
    rencontre+bath
    boys+bath
    demenagement+bath
    bath+fuck
    bath+spa
    hotel+bath
    bath+cum
    clawfoot+bath+tubs
    bath+boys
    pee+bath
    bath+young
    bath+girls
    sperm+bath
    naked+bath
    bath+party
    fucking+bath
    bath+fucking
    first+bath
    as+bath
    bath+body+imagine+love+perfume+works
    bath+beauty
    shemale+bath
    bath+mature
    bath+robe
    biarritz+bath
    bath+gift+sets
    dog+bath
    steam+bath
    bath+duck
    fuck+bath
    spy+bath
    bath+accesories
    young+bath
    asian+bath
    bath+spy
    bath+apercu
    bath+big
    bath+gay
    bed+bath+and+beyond
    mud+bath

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>