No article has filled me with more trepidation and suspicion about Hancock than last Sunday's N.Y. Times piece by Michael Cieply. It's supposed to be about a superhero flick that pushes limits in terms of the main character's behavior, but all I got out of it were a bunch of pretending-to-be-concerned-or-thoughtful comments from a lot of smug over-paid people who ride around in pricey cars.

I really don't like that photo of producer Akiva Goldsman laughing uproariously while standing next to Will Smith. Too many people laugh in that man's presence. Smith himself,now that you mention it, laughs and smiles too much also. I just don't like the vibe coming off this film. The trailer was half-appealing, but Cieply has killed the vibe.
Posted by Jeffrey Wells on May 6, 2008 at 6:55 AM
comment #1
giantman
says ...
That picture freaks me out as well and I totally agree with the feeling the article gives. In the end though, what matters is what is on the screen and I'm willing to wait and see, this one intrigues me - it is either brilliant or stupid. And isn't that what being on the edge is all about?
Posted by giantman
at May 6, 2008 7:24 AM
comment #2
Rich S.
says ...
"And in the movie, I play the last man alive on Earth! Everyone else is dead! And vampire mutants prowl the city thirsting for my blood! I tell you, it's a laff riot!"
Posted by Rich S.
at May 6, 2008 7:42 AM
comment #3
Walter Sobchak
says ...
"So it's basically this: Will Smith, some classic, well-placed catch-phrases, a shit-load of noise and eye-popping CGI. Eh? Eh?"
"I like it. I really like it. What's it called"?
"Hancock."
"Nice. Kind of has a 'Cloverfield' sound to it. And once we build product recognition it can be simply 'H'. I can see it. 'Smith...H...Summer 08!' Call Tamara in. I think we've got something."
Posted by Walter Sobchak
at May 6, 2008 7:45 AM
comment #4
actionman
says ...
The article has only made me want to see this film even more. This is not going to be a cookie-cutter action flick and it sounds about as edgy as the pg-13 rating will allow.
Considering this has been a Michael Mann passion project (in one form or another) for the last decade almost, I am more than excited at seeing an edgy superhero film that arrives with a Mann stamp of approval. Before him, this was Tony Scott's, and I remember when I was working for him (about 6 years ago), I read an early draft of this script by Vincent Ngo. I remember saying to myself (and this was before the superhero movie explosion) that this would be just about the most different take on the whole genre. And even though there have been numerous re-writes, Ngo's core ideas are still in tact. We'll see how the final product turns out, but the addition of Peter Berg only heightens my excitement.
The film has always been a dark send-up of the entire superhero movie mythology, while also adding a level of over-the-top action to the proceedings.
Cieply's article makes the film out to be flying under the radar, or as under the radar as a big-budget summer movie like this can
Posted by actionman
at May 6, 2008 7:49 AM
comment #5
K. Bowen
says ...
My favorite moment in an Akiva Goldsman script is the moment in Cinderella Man where Russell Crowe walks into the ring, and the ringside radio annoucers describes everything, including the crowd reaction for the audience. Um, we can see what the crowd is doing. That's the miracle of cinema. You can actually see things happening.
Posted by K. Bowen
at May 6, 2008 7:56 AM
comment #6
vansmith
says ...
there wont be any mid air sex scenes, or flying while drunk. it will be cute, but there will probably be a 'what might have been' feeling when you leave the theater..
Posted by vansmith
at May 6, 2008 8:15 AM
comment #7
frank2,5
says ...
check out the int. trailer @ http://www.sonypictures.se/doc/trailer.jsp?tl=HANCOCK&pd=2008-07-18&dir=hancock
that should give you a better idea of what they mean when they call hancock "superhero flick that pushes limits in terms of the main character's behavior"
Posted by frank2,5
at May 6, 2008 8:20 AM
comment #8
MickTravis
says ...
"Too many people laugh in that man's presence. Smith himself,now that you mention it, laughs and smiles too much also."
I didn't mention it -- you did -- but I whole-heartedly agree.
Laughing and smiling are just a way of puttin' on airs, tellin' people you're better than them. Far too many people laugh and smile nowadays. What the hell are they so happy about?
And why does beer always have to be served so cold? Doesn't anybody realize that some people like it warm or even hot? Jeez!
Posted by MickTravis
at May 6, 2008 9:08 AM
comment #9
berkguru
says ...
will smith is a putz
movie looks dumb - if most people were given super hero powers they would be out raping and pillaging and satisfying all of our animal desires
only one that remotely portrayed that accurately was Kevin Bacon in the Hollow Man but that took Paul Verhooven to make it happen
Posted by berkguru
at May 6, 2008 9:23 AM
comment #10
vansmith
says ...
it does look dumb, even the CG, throwing the whale like that is funny in theory but it looked cheesy. and the wise cracks you know there are plenty. i wanted to see him and charlize get it on..
Posted by vansmith
at May 6, 2008 9:38 AM
comment #11
JohnCope
says ...
Goldsman is a horrifying hack and his continued employment says everything that needs be said about the state of Hollywood. His script for Batman and Robin, just as a for instance, is atrocious grabage and one of the worst pieces of writing ever committed to the screen. He should be hoisted up at the Burning Man festival.
Posted by JohnCope
at May 6, 2008 9:44 AM
comment #12
lesterg
says ...
I'm still getting a major Last Action Hero vibe off this film, but I'm certain it will be more successful than that.
Posted by lesterg
at May 6, 2008 9:50 AM
comment #13
diesel
says ...
I think there's no denying the fact that almost everything Smith touches of late becomes gold, and so wiill this. I liked the first trailer better though. Guess it was the music.
I remember an interview Letterman did with Smith where Smith called Tom Cruise a genius. Two times. If not three. That made me doubt the man.
On another note, the Blu-ray copy of Zodiac Director's Cut was is released in Sweden tomorrow. My copy's already been dispatched. Amazon.co.uk has a release date of Sep 1. Amazon.com doesn't even list a Blu-ray copy.
Posted by diesel
at May 6, 2008 9:54 AM
comment #14
actionman
says ...
I am not an Akiva Goldsman fan at all, though a few of his projects have been entertaining (Constantine, Mr & Mrs Smith, I Am Legend, The Client, Cinderalla Man, Starsky and Hutch). He shot be beaten for his work on Batman and Robin, Lost in Space and The Davinci Code).
What excites me about the project is the involvement of Peter Berg and Michael Mann.
Posted by actionman
at May 6, 2008 9:58 AM
comment #15
actionman
says ...
Meant to say he "should" be beaten, not "shot" be beaten...
Posted by actionman
at May 6, 2008 10:01 AM
comment #16
corey3rd
says ...
what was golden about Wild Wild West?
Posted by corey3rd
at May 6, 2008 10:02 AM
comment #17
Balthazar
says ...
I would say that Akiva is the Anti-Christ, but I'm fairly sure that, by definition, the Anti-Christ has at least a little talent and creativity up his sleeve.
Posted by Balthazar
at May 6, 2008 10:42 AM
comment #18
sutter kane
says ...
However you feel about Will Smith personally, if I were him (two best actor nods, dozens of movies over $100 million, and arguably the most bankable movie star in the world) I'd be smiling and laughing a lot, too. I kind of get the vibe Jeff's talking about, but give the guy a break. I'd be more weirded out if Smith was Sean-Penn-morose all the time.
Posted by sutter kane
at May 6, 2008 10:45 AM
comment #19
BurmaShave
says ...
Akiva Goldsman- 1, Peter O'Toole- 0
Posted by BurmaShave
at May 6, 2008 11:24 AM
comment #20
Gabriel
says ...
"My favorite moment in an Akiva Goldsman script is the moment in Cinderella Man where Russell Crowe walks into the ring, and the ringside radio annoucers describes everything, including the crowd reaction for the audience. Um, we can see what the crowd is doing. That's the miracle of cinema. You can actually see things happening."
I don't know if this was in the script - I'm guessing it was - but I loved the part where they talked for 10 straight minutes about how Paddy Considine's character is staying in Hooverville.
Cut to: Next scene, with a title card reading "Hooverville".
Posted by Gabriel
at May 6, 2008 11:55 AM
comment #21
High Chaparral
says ...
As a book, The DaVinci Code was only a few INTs and EXTs away from being a script.
And still Goldsman fucked it up.
Posted by High Chaparral
at May 6, 2008 12:21 PM
comment #22
Arizona Joe
says ...
Akiva Goldsman is part of a Hollywood cabal of self-satisfaction and mediocrity. It sells and perpetuates itself.
Posted by Arizona Joe
at May 6, 2008 12:40 PM
comment #23
SaveFarris
says ...
"but all I got out of it were a bunch of pretending-to-be-concerned-or-thoughtful comments from a lot of smug over-paid people who ride around in pricey cars."
The Barack Obama Experience!!
Posted by SaveFarris
at May 6, 2008 12:57 PM
comment #24
Edward
says ...
Not to defend Akiva Goldsman, but in regards to K. Bowen's posting about Cinderella Man. The announcer would be describing everything, because he's broadcasting to a radio audience.
Posted by Edward
at May 6, 2008 2:28 PM
comment #25
Josh Massey
says ...
Akiva Goldsman is a godawful stain on Hollywood, ... but. From being around Smith just a little bit, I can tell you I've never met a guy who absolutely electrified a room the way he does. I don't mean to overstate this, but people just got happier when he was around. It's what a lot of people (used to) say about Bill Clinton. Just an energy.
Posted by Josh Massey
at May 6, 2008 4:00 PM
comment #26
Radewart
says ...
Jeff's hating on Smith for laughing and smiling is pretty petty. It feels like the weird outcast high school kid hating on the captain of the football team. Jealousy is an awful thing Jeff.
Posted by Radewart
at May 7, 2008 10:45 AM
comment #27
Radewart
says ...
Plus Obams wants Smith to play him in a movie.
Posted by Radewart
at May 7, 2008 10:46 AM