Two in a Row

I don't feel like writing anything now, but I'm now officially thumbs-up on Milk and Frost/Nixon. On a 1 to 10 scale, I'm giving them both an 8.5 -- and that ain't hay. Others are going to bestow 9 or 9.5 ratings, and that's fine also.


Daylight tells you this was taken prior to this evening's Milk premiere at the Castro. Photo by Randy Matthews.

I've been hearing iffy things about Milk for the last week or so, but I have to conclude that those who've been spreading the iffy stuff are by and large mean-spirited and, I feel, overly demanding. Milk cares, holds back, pushes through and gets it done. It's compassionate, exacting, precisely ordered and emotional in most of the right ways. As for Frost/Nixon...well, I've seen the stage play and was ready for the worst, but I really don't get what the London haters were on about.

I felt a genuine gayness from Sean Penn, who plays the title role of the late San Francisco supervisor Harvey Milk, that I didn't think he had in him. Emile Hirsch and James Franco give the stand-out supporting perfs.

I was down with Ron Howard's film from start to finish. It's very well done, very full and expert for what it is. It's more satisfying, more underlined (but in a subtle way) and more clearly wrought than the play, frankly. It's not Kubrick, Bresson, Kazan, Eisenstein, Welles, the Coen brothers or Lubitsch. It is what it is, and that's in no way a problem. And it significantly improves upon what it was on the New York stage.

And Frank Langella's performance as Richard Nixon is naturally and necessarily more toned down than it was on-stage, and that, Honest Injun, makes it a fascinating, moving (as in genuinely sad), award-level effort.

Take Stock, Americans<< previous | next >>Milk Quickie

Posted by Jeffrey Wells on October 28, 2008 at 10:48 PM

comment #1

Devin Faraci Author Profile Page says ...

I only saw one of those films, but the one I saw had an almost terrible first half saved by a good second half.

Posted by Devin Faraci Author Profile Page at October 28, 2008 11:20 PM

comment #2

mtgilchrist Author Profile Page says ...

I was at the same screening of Frost/Nixon tonight and while I was slightly less enthusiastic about the film than you were, I admit that i was distracted by a woman sitting in the row in front of me who was inexplicably taking pictures of the film. Not "filming" it per se but taking pictures with her iPhone. I was just out of range of saying something during the movie, but thankfully my colleague next to me did and she stopped. After the screening it took a considerable amount of restraint for me not to approach her and ask what reason she possibly could have imagined in order to think it's appropriate to do that. Worse yet, she wasn't some teenager dicking around but a 55+ woman who at least by all outward evidence was not possessed of mental illness or incapacity. Seriously, WTF?

Posted by mtgilchrist Author Profile Page at October 28, 2008 11:40 PM

comment #3

Devin Faraci Author Profile Page says ...

Did you tell a publicist? That shit's piracy.

Posted by Devin Faraci Author Profile Page at October 28, 2008 11:48 PM

comment #4

Scott Feinberg Author Profile Page says ...

Jeff, I was getting the same BS tips about "Milk" being a disappointment, and then I saw it today and happen to think it's terrific, especially--but far from exclusively--Penn. The bad buzz actually only lowered expectations and made the movie all the more rewarding... but, still, you've gotta wonder where this stuff starts, and why it sometimes builds to the point that usually-credible people start circulating it to us.

Posted by Scott Feinberg Author Profile Page at October 28, 2008 11:48 PM

comment #5

huntermdaniels Author Profile Page says ...

Ron Howard is no great director in my estimation so it's no surprise that it's not Kubrick.

Posted by huntermdaniels Author Profile Page at October 28, 2008 11:57 PM

comment #6

mtgilchrist Author Profile Page says ...

Thankfully my colleague was equally outraged and he bopped her chair with the fancy program they gave us, so she stopped. But the situation was one of those classic "how badly do I want to interrupt my own enjoyment of this movie" instances, and I was smack in the middle of a full theater.

Posted by mtgilchrist Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 12:40 AM

comment #7

A.H. Author Profile Page says ...

The trailer for Milk shows Emile Hirsch's character saying "I don't 'do' losing." I'm pretty sure people didn't talk that way in 1974. Is the rest of the movie filled with anachronisms like that?

Posted by A.H. Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 12:56 AM

comment #8

A.H. Author Profile Page says ...

Oops, I mean 1978. Same question still applies. :)

Posted by A.H. Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 12:59 AM

comment #9

Kristopher Tapley Author Profile Page says ...

Come off the conspiracy theory shit, Scott. There are some people who genuinely have issues with "Milk" and their concerns aren't totally unfounded. Just because they disagree doesn't mean they're somehow "wrong." Don't puff yourself and your "tips" into something their not.

Posted by Kristopher Tapley Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 1:07 AM

comment #10

BurmaShave Author Profile Page says ...

Sorry to D.Z., but where the hell is the buzz on this film?:

http://www.worstpreviews.com/trailer.php?id=1326&item=0

Or is that not a US release date?

Posted by BurmaShave Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 3:49 AM

comment #11

guylodge Author Profile Page says ...

"London haters" is a bit strong, I think. For one, I certainly didn't HATE the film -- it's too intelligent and well-crafted for that. I just felt no emotional connection while watching it.

Posted by guylodge Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 4:25 AM

comment #12

Gordie Lachance Author Profile Page says ...

Oh, how I would love to see the words "I felt a genuine gayness from Sean Penn" on a poster for this.


On another note, re. Hirsch's "I don't do losing". Who's to say what was or wasn't said back in the 70's? (especially in a hip ahead-of-the-curve neighborhood like Castro).

I mean they used to call guns gats back in the 1920's, but I'm sure most people think thats a 1990's hip hop thing.

Posted by Gordie Lachance Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 4:33 AM

comment #13

HarveyCo Author Profile Page says ...

re: "Thankfully my colleague was equally outraged and he bopped her chair with the fancy program they gave us, so she stopped."

That was no woman, man. That was Roger Ebert!

re: "On another note, re. Hirsch's "I don't do losing". Who's to say what was or wasn't said back in the 70's?"

Maybe, like, people who were around during the 70's? Can we find any? Are they all dead? Are they in special homes? Oh, wait, I'm one of them. But I was very little.

Posted by HarveyCo Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 5:35 AM

comment #14

Zimmergirl Author Profile Page says ...

There is too much pressure, early pressure on these movies to "pass" or "fail."

Posted by Zimmergirl Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 5:45 AM

comment #15

LDKA0186 Author Profile Page says ...

Wells, I know you said this wasn’t a proper write-up, but, man…this is some sloppy writing all around. Even for a “first impressions” thing, this is weak. Now, a couple of days ago you got on someone for saying they hated Manohla Dargis without clearly explaining why. After much thought, here’s why this blog fails:

1) You have got to stop with the faux-straight talk. “And that ain't hay” and “Honest Injun” are the worst examples here. It’s cutesy and phony sounding, as opposed to honest and direct, and the Western feel it creates (which, to be honest, is more “Wild Wild West” than “Deadwood”) is particularly incongruous with your subject matter—two politically charged movies set in 1970s California. Cut this stuff. If you pride yourself on straight talk, then just say something. Don’t then give a folksy expression to demonstrate directness. It’s unnecessary.

2) “I felt a genuine gayness from Sean Penn…that I didn't think he had in him.” Wow. Here’s the thing: the sentiment here works. Sean Penn specializes in macho types, so your surprise that he could so fully sublimate himself into the soul of a gay man is understandable. But, my God, your phrasing sucks! “I felt a genuine gayness?” Really? Again, not “direct and true,” but borderline insensitive and childish; it makes you seem distant from and uncertain about gay people. Maybe you are, I don’t know, but even so, you don’t need to draw attention to that fact. If you ever write a real review, rephrase this.

3) “It's not Kubrick, Bresson, Kazan, Eisenstein, Welles, the Coen brothers or Lubitsch.” Again, more sloppy writing. What do these guys have to do with “Frost/Nixon?” If I missed something, please fill me in, but it seems like you’re name-dropping just to name-drop. What do you achieve comparing this movie to ones it’s nothing like? It doesn’t add meaningful texture to your piece; all it does is bog your writing down with unnecessary details. And subtly, it is a critique of the movie—why list these other guys unless you want us to be thinking about them when we see Howard’s film?

4) Even in your longer reviews, you have a tendency to list rather than to critique. For example, look at “It's compassionate, exacting, precisely ordered and emotional.” Okay, that’s a decent beginning to some criticism (if more-than-a-little unwieldy—pick the strongest two of those and ditch the rest to make a clearer, more forceful point). Now explain what they mean. How the cinematography or the script creates a “precisely ordered” feel. How a certain scene is “compassionate” or “emotional.” You get my drift. The biggest problem with your listing is that you do it all the time; after this example, we get, “It's very well done, very full and expert,” “It's more satisfying, more underlined…and more clearly wrought,” and “Milk cares, holds back, pushes through and gets it done.” In those first two cases, again, explain further. That last one, though, “Milk cares, holds back, pushes through and gets it done…” that one doesn’t even make any sense. I guess you mean the movie proceeds with admirable restraint until the emotionally devastating climax, but your way evokes either a) pro-wrestling or b) porn. If you wanted that effect, my apologies. If not, I’d consider a rewrite. And one last thing about listing: when you list more than three things, you add commas between each example. No exceptions. It’s not, “Milk cares, holds back, pushes through and gets it done,” but rather, “Milk cares, holds back, pushes through, and gets it done.” Leaving out that last one is confusing—it makes the last two examples seem like one compound example.

You blogged about us leaving thoughtful comments to respect you and this site. Well, we readers deserve a little of your respect. Put a little more care into your writing.

Posted by LDKA0186 Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 7:16 AM

comment #16

Leonardcoenbrothers Author Profile Page says ...

Wow LDKA0186, you clearly have a lot of free time. You forgot to assign a letter grade, and to tell Jeff if he can do some extra credit work to help raise his grade point average.

Posted by Leonardcoenbrothers Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 7:38 AM

comment #17

corey3rd Author Profile Page says ...

I remember a Happy Day's episode with the Fonz saying he "don't do"....

Posted by corey3rd Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 7:58 AM

comment #18

The Playlist Author Profile Page says ...

I very much agree. Milk is terrific. I think it had some really creative stuff in it that made it land somewhere between My Private Idaho and Goodwill Hunting on the aesthetics scale. However, i suppose i can see that it's not a masterpiece, but certainly the strongest Oscar-bait so far.

Posted by The Playlist Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 8:00 AM

comment #19

gruver1 Author Profile Page says ...

Wells to LDKAO186: I'm aware that just listing adjectives and failing to provide examples of this and that in the proper context doesn't make for a complete and fully considered review. I said at the beginning of the post that I didn't feel like writing anything so I tapped out a general thumbnail impression of both films. Since I was mainly relying on short declarations and many adjectives, I used adjectives that felt right to me. I can tap out a real review of Frost/Nixon later today, and one of Milk when the mood suits and the blood is up. I've been writing fairly well and in some instances very well on this site for years. Sometimes I surprise even myself; sometimes I'm just digging ditches. I know how good I am, what my strengths and ineffective tendencies are. But I don't agree and will NEVER agree with using a comma prior to the word "and."

Posted by gruver1 Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 8:00 AM

comment #20

dcc77 Author Profile Page says ...

2) Separate three or more items in a series with a comma. Example: "We want to protect cats, dogs, and horses."

www.drgrammar.org/faqs/#37

Jeff, LDKA overstated his case and lost sight of the reality: this is a blog, not The New Yorker. Anthony Lane et al spend hours researching and crafting their pieces; they're not running a one-man news organization like you are. Of course you're an excellent writer.

That said, I always add the final comma in a list like Dr. Grammar recommends. It feels like overkill but for the sake of clarity -- LDKA's one unquestionably salient point -- you need to include it.

Posted by dcc77 Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 8:39 AM

comment #21

Gordie Lachance Author Profile Page says ...

Harvey Co-

My point was not that the 70's were so long ago, but rather that prior to cable television and the internet, regional slang and colloquialisms were passed from person to person and might never have gotten a broader usage. You wouldn't know unless you were there. But it's perfectly believable that Hirsch's character could have said that.

Anyway, the trailer sold me on Milk. Looks fantastic.

Posted by Gordie Lachance Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 8:44 AM

comment #22

HarveyCo Author Profile Page says ...

re: "You wouldn't know unless you were there. But it's perfectly believable that Hirsch's character could have said that."

Why? Were you there?

Posted by HarveyCo Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 9:30 AM

comment #23

great scott Author Profile Page says ...

So is Frost/Nixon back in the Oscar Balloon again?

Posted by great scott Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 9:51 AM

comment #24

Gordie Lachance Author Profile Page says ...

Sorry Harvey, didn't realize you were just a troll. You win. Have a nice day.

Posted by Gordie Lachance Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 10:11 AM

comment #25

HarveyCo Author Profile Page says ...

Sorry Gordie, forgot you don't have a sense of humor. Which is a poor reflection on me because most of your posts shout that out loud.

Posted by HarveyCo Author Profile Page at October 29, 2008 10:41 AM

comment #26

Hal Author Profile Page says ...

The negatives pointed out by those UK reviewers are no less valid, but it should be kept in mind that there is often a kind of anti-Ron-Howard/Americana parochialism, thanks to a British scripted stage play being made on the other side of the pond.

Posted by Hal Author Profile Page at October 30, 2008 12:39 AM

comment #27

mark09 Author Profile Page says ...

The fact that one guy has already begun to tire of Cera's act may sound ludicrous, but it also suggests that perhaps he is playing the same tune over and over. masters degree business AND Information Technology degree

Posted by mark09 Author Profile Page at October 9, 2009 11:50 PM

comment #28

mark09 Author Profile Page says ...

While I haven't seen Cera's work yet, he seems a little more believable than Leo. But unlike Leo, and more like Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Cera's deliberately trying to avoid being the pompous teen idol big shot. That's not necessarily a bad thing, though. It might help both of them develop the kind of name-brand reliability and appeal which helped boost Depp's comeback. Animation degree AND Online Marketing degree AND bachelor degree business

Posted by mark09 Author Profile Page at October 9, 2009 11:50 PM

comment #29

air nike shoes Author Profile Page says ...

I only saw one of those films, but the one I saw had an almost terrible first half saved by a good second half.

Posted by air nike shoes Author Profile Page at October 10, 2009 5:37 AM

comment #30

yoursite Author Profile Page says ...

There is too much pressure. I only saw one of those films online.

Posted by yoursite Author Profile Page at December 15, 2009 8:48 PM

Posted by AaronKer Author Profile Page at February 23, 2010 7:23 AM

comment #32

jimb12345 Author Profile Page says ...

I am giving the movie a 9. I think it was amazing to watch.
boca raton veneers

Posted by jimb12345 Author Profile Page at February 23, 2010 4:31 PM

comment #33

filerecovery Author Profile Page says ...

I remember a Happy Day's episode with the Fonz saying he "don't do"....
Guard Process|Restore Deleted Files|进程保护

Posted by filerecovery Author Profile Page at February 24, 2010 8:40 PM

comment #34

wenwen Author Profile Page says ...

ed hardyed hardy

Gucci HandbagsGucci Handbags

Louis VuittonLouis Vuitton

Columbia SportswearColumbia Sportswear

Links Of LondonLinks Of London

Posted by wenwen Author Profile Page at February 26, 2010 9:20 PM

comment #35

teayneverdie Author Profile Page says ...

Acer AO532h-2730 Acer AO532h-2588 Acer AO532h-2223 Gateway LT2108u VPCF114FX H - Review Loest Price for Sony VAIO VPC-F114FX/H VPCF113FX B - Review Sony VAIO VPC-F113FX/B VPCCW21FX/L Acer AO532h-2406 Acer AO532h-2964 Acer AO532h-2309 Axion AXN-8905 Coby TFTV1212 LG 32LH20 Panasonic TC-L26X1 Panasonic TC-P50G10 Samsung 2333HD Samsung LN19B361 Samsung LN22B360 Samsung LN26B360 Samsung LN26B460 Samsung LN32B360 Samsung LN32B460 Samsung LN40B630 Samsung LN40B650 samsung LN40B750 Samsung LN46B530 Samsung LN52B550 Samsung LN52B630 Samsung PN58B650 Samsung UN32B6000 Samsung UN46B8500 Samsung UN55B8500 Toshiba 15LV506 Toshiba 19LV610U Toshiba 19LV610U Toshiba 26LV610U Viore LED22VF60 VIZIO VM230XVT

Acer Laptop
Acer AO532h-2382 Acer AO532h-2406 Acer AO532h-2964 Acer AS1410-2954 Acer AS3810T-8737 Acer AS4810TZ-4183 Acer AS7540-1317 Acer AS1410-2990 Acer D250-1413 Acer AS1410-2920 Acer AS1410-2706 Acer AS5740-5513
Asus Laptop
ASUS 900HDB-BLK003X ASUS 1001P-PU17-BK ASUS 1001P-PU17-WT ASUS 1005PE-PU17-BU ASUS G72Gx-A1 BenQ W6000
Gatewat Laptop
Gateway LT2106u Gateway LT2110u Gateway LT2113u Gateway LT2114u Gateway LT2118u Gateway LT2119u Gateway LT2120u Gateway EC1457u Gateway NV5923u
HP Laptop
HP 210-1080NR HP 311-1025NR HP DV7-3160US HP TouchSmart 300-1020
Toshiba Laptop
Toshiba NB305-N310 Toshiba NB305-N410WH Toshiba Qosmio X505-Q880 Toshiba T115D-S1120 Compaq CQ61-410US HP Pavilion DV6-2150US
Sony Product
Sony VAIO VPC-W211AX/W Sony VAIO VPC-W211AX/T Sony VPCF111FX H Sony HDR-XR550V Sony HDR-XR150
Canon Cameras
Canon A3100 IS Canon A3100 IS Canon A495 Canon VIXIA HF M30 Dual Flash Memory Camcorder
ViZIO Product
VIZIO SV422XVT VIZIO VF552XVT VIZIO SV472XVT VIZIO VBR200W Viore LC24VXF60PB
Kodak Product
Kodak EasyShare C142 Kodak EasyShare D825 Kodak EasyShare M530
JVC Product
JVC GZ-HM550 JVC GZ-MS230
Other Product
Lenovo S10-3t Casio EX-FH100 Samsung HZ25W Sharp LC22DV27UT

Posted by teayneverdie Author Profile Page at February 27, 2010 1:19 AM

comment #36

love Author Profile Page says ...

ugg boots

Posted by love Author Profile Page at March 5, 2010 8:54 PM

comment #37

niuniu2012 Author Profile Page says ...

You can use DVD to MP3 Converter to select target subtitle and audio track according at your will. DVD to MP3 Converter also provides you with fruitful options to set audio properties of audio bitrate, Sample Rate and so on.

Posted by niuniu2012 Author Profile Page at March 10, 2010 5:24 PM

comment #38

martinlusin Author Profile Page says ...

Thanks man oyunlardizi izle vakantie

Posted by martinlusin Author Profile Page at June 26, 2010 9:48 AM

comment #39

how to make money Author Profile Page says ...

nice post i loved it a lot worth readable and very informative thanks for sharing with us. keep the job up
Very good job. I just found your blog and wanted to say I really enjoyed reading your blog.
make money

Posted by how to make money Author Profile Page at September 4, 2010 11:51 AM

comment #40

fouray Author Profile Page says ...

Dizi izle

Posted by fouray Author Profile Page at September 22, 2010 7:46 AM

comment #41

lily4563 Author Profile Page says ...

I went to watch this movie and even they created a good promotion it was good enough I wasn't happy with the result and I have to say that the best past of that night it was dinner. Generic Viagra

Posted by lily4563 Author Profile Page at October 22, 2010 8:00 AM

comment #42

Rexanfrancis Author Profile Page says ...

Thank you for this nice post

my blogs: master cleanse | diets that work

Posted by Rexanfrancis Author Profile Page at November 27, 2010 2:18 AM

comment #43

iddaa Author Profile Page says ...

I read this blog pretty often, based just on the titles that I find at hollywood-elsewhere, and I am consistently pleased with the writing quality that I find here.
justin tv izle
justin tv
lig tv izle
d smart izle
basketbol izle

Posted by iddaa Author Profile Page at January 8, 2011 10:39 AM

comment #44

hzcy Author Profile Page says ...

I went to watch this movie Electronic insect killer and Extension cords even they created a good promotion iExtension socket was good enough I wasn't happy Flash lighting with the result and I have to Germany extension socket say that the best past of that night Glam hangers was dinner.

Posted by hzcy Author Profile Page at February 22, 2011 5:06 PM

comment #45

hzcy Author Profile Page says ...

If you could transport this issue back in time, replace it with the issue of whether or not to rebel against England, and the diplomacy necessary to gain assistance from France, you might have the same feelings about Ben Franklin. Germany type socket glue gun Holland type socket Inspection Lamp led lamp

Posted by hzcy Author Profile Page at February 22, 2011 6:16 PM

comment #46

hzcy Author Profile Page says ...

Personal privacy is a staple of our rights. If we choose to surrender our privacy it is a matter of choice. led lamp Mop Noise Filter Socket Padded Hanger PDU

Posted by hzcy Author Profile Page at February 22, 2011 6:42 PM

comment #47

istanbulhotel Author Profile Page says ...

istanbul hotels

istanbul airport
transfer

Posted by istanbulhotel Author Profile Page at February 24, 2011 4:02 AM

comment #48

youtube converter mp4 Author Profile Page says ...

Thanks for your patience and sorry for the inconvenience!
Best regards, Mary, CEO of mp3 from youtube and install windows 7 on iscsi

Posted by youtube converter mp4 Author Profile Page at March 1, 2011 1:44 AM

comment #49

Sammby Author Profile Page says ...

You know, I love read all this article updates because I a movie geek.. I would like to read about every movie review. Led lights

Posted by Sammby Author Profile Page at March 11, 2011 4:56 AM

Posted by Nicholas Cage Author Profile Page at May 17, 2011 1:10 PM

comment #51

kerry Author Profile Page says ...

Si vous etes interesses par le dossier, ou desirez en savoir plus, contactez-moi par mail, et je vous mettrai en contact.
Best regards,Jane, CEO of storage area network solutions

Posted by kerry Author Profile Page at June 1, 2011 1:00 AM

Posted by ewet Author Profile Page at June 25, 2011 3:55 PM

Posted by bob Author Profile Page at July 29, 2011 3:30 PM

Posted by Linaroy Author Profile Page at August 21, 2011 7:48 AM

comment #55

Linaroy Author Profile Page says ...

Thanks for the great idea i really appriciate you to sharing your research.
payday loan | payday loans

Posted by Linaroy Author Profile Page at August 21, 2011 7:49 AM

Posted by belstaff Author Profile Page at August 29, 2011 11:22 PM

comment #57

Cheap wedding dresses Author Profile Page says ...

I just stumbledformal dresses upon your blog and wanted to2011 wedding dresses say that I have really enjoyed readingpluz size wedding dresses your blog posts.

Posted by Cheap wedding dresses Author Profile Page at October 19, 2011 9:47 PM

comment #58

mary Author Profile Page says ...

You made some good points .I did a little research on the topic and found that most people agree with your blog. Thanks.
buy ritalin online

Posted by mary Author Profile Page at December 16, 2011 8:34 AM

comment #59

Abra Author Profile Page says ...

Amazing!I also wish him good luck to defend his gold medal. I like to share it with all my friends and hope they will also encourage him.
buy percocet online

Posted by Abra Author Profile Page at December 21, 2011 6:40 AM

comment #60

medicine forum Author Profile Page says ...

This is good site to spent time on .I just stumbled upon your informative blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your very well written blog posts. I will be your frequent visitor, that's for sure.

Posted by medicine forum Author Profile Page at January 9, 2012 10:32 AM

Leave a comment