Taking Woodstock

email this story
read comments (52)
post a comment

I don't know what I was expecting exactly from Ang Lee's Taking Woodstock (Focus Features, 8.14.09), which had its first big press screening this afternoon at the Cannes Film Festival, but what I saw didn't deliver. This backstory saga about the legendary Woodstock Music Festival of '69 works in spots and spurts, but it too often feels ragged and unsure of itself, and doesn't coalesce in a way that feels truly solid or self-knowing.

At best it's a decent try, an in-and-outer. Spit it out -- it's a letdown. I've talked to a few critic friends since the 4:30 screening got out and all but one are feeling and saying the same.

I wish it were otherwise. I'd like to be more obliging because I love many of Lee's films and fully respect his talent. I remember and cherish the spirit and the legend of the 1969 Woodstock Music Festival. I'm looking forward to watching the forthcoming Warner Home Video Bluray of Michael Wadleigh's 1970 documentary (out June 9th). And I appreciate what a massive undertaking it must have been to try and recreate it all within a dramatic prism.

James Schamus's script is based on the story of Eliot Tiber, the artist who stepped in and pretty much saved the disenfranchised festival by finagling a land permit in Bethel, New York. (The source is a same-titled book by Tiber and Tom Monte.) The story is basically about how a closeted gay Jewish guy got over feeling obliged to help his parents survive by helping them run their rundown El Monaco motel in White Lake, N.Y., and freed himself to live his own life.

This story comes through but it feels analagous to a story of the D-Day Invasion that focuses on Francois, a closeted young man in his 30s who doesn't want to work at his parents' Normandy bakery any more. ("Merci, General Eisenhower, for allowing me to move to Nice and be openly gay!") And the Eliot story is weakened, in my book, by Imelda Staunton's strident and braying portrayal of Tiber's mother-from-hell. I've known my share of Jewish moms and I didn't believe her. Nobody is that humorless or stupid (in terms of recognizing economic opportunity) or dark-hearted.

And as noted, the big sprawling back-saga of how the festival came together -- the element that audiences will be coming to see when it opens -- too often feels catch-as-catch-can. It doesn't seem to develop or intensify, and there's no clean sense of chronology. (And there's at least one glaring inaccuracy when a random festivalgoer declares a day or two before the event begins that "it's a free concert, man...haven't you heard?" My recollection is that it wasn't declared free until the concert had begun and the fences had come down and the organizers realized they'd lost control.)

Taking Woodstock should have been dated here and there like The Longest Day. That way, at least, we'd have an idea of how many days are left before the festival begins, a sense of "okay, getting closer, things are heating up."

Lee references Wadleigh's 1970 doc by using the same split-screen editing style and by shooting it with a semblance of '70s grainy color. But no Woodstock concert footage is mixed into Lee's movie, and this just seems unfulfilling somehow. It's a shame that Lee and Schamus (who also produced) and Focus Features couldn't have worked out a cross-promotional deal with Warner Bros. that would have allowed for this. I kept telling myself that it's Eliot's story, not Woodstock II, but I wanted glimpses of the real thing, dammit.

Comedian Demetri Martin is steady and likable as Tiber, although too much of the time he's been directed to look overwhelmed or mildly freaked. (This was a man of 34 who'd been around a bit -- Martin plays him like Dustin Hoffman's Benjamin Braddock.) Eugene Levy is quite good as Max Yagur, the kindly but shrewd dairy farmer who leased the land to Woodstock Ventures. Liev Schreiber delivers a mildly amusing turn as Vilma, a blond-haired cross-dresser whom Eliot hires to provide security for the El Monaco, but his character has no real function or arc -- he's just providing Greek-chorus commentary. Jonathan Groff does a decent job as Michael Lang, the most well-known of the concert promoters, playing him as a serenely confident Zen type. (I loved the way he gets around on horseback in the second half of the film, whether or not that's accurate -- it's a good bit.)

Emile Hirsch, Ang Lee during shooting.

It may be impossible to have characters speak in '60s cliches without the effort feeling tiresome, but that's what happens here. I realize that people actually used the terms "groovy" and "far out, man" back then, but every time you hear them in the film...God!

Taking Woodstock was just too big an undertaking, I suppose. In the same way that Lang and his partners instigated but couldn't control the enormity and chaos of the '69 festival, Lee was also overwhelmed. Tough fame, tough call, I'm sorry. Better luck next time.

Bop Around<< previous | next >>Finally Saw Precious

Posted by Jeffrey Wells on May 15, 2009 at 9:52 AM

comment #1

actionman says ...

Yikes. Wasn't expecting this review from you, Wells. Sounds very "mezzo-mezzo," to borrow one of your best catch-phrases.

Posted by actionman at May 15, 2009 12:46 PM

comment #2

Josh Massey says ...

So Ang Lee has gone Wachowski on us?

(This will make a lot less sense once the second picture is corrected).

Posted by Josh Massey at May 15, 2009 12:56 PM

comment #3

scooterzz says ...

jm --- i was thinking more lee tamahori

Posted by scooterzz at May 15, 2009 1:12 PM

comment #4

movie8435 says ...

Too bad. I had high hopes for this film. Ang Lee is greatness!

Posted by movie8435 at May 15, 2009 2:14 PM

comment #5

Ryansi51 says ...

eh. i really never even gave this a chance. always seemed like a complete outsider trying to capture the hippie vibe.

Posted by Ryansi51 at May 15, 2009 3:09 PM

comment #6

Josh Massey says ...

For an outsider, he wonderfully captured the '70s suburban American and gay cowboy vibes.

Posted by Josh Massey at May 15, 2009 3:16 PM

comment #7

DarienStyles says ...

Would you have said the same thing, had the lead been heterosexual?

Posted by DarienStyles at May 15, 2009 3:22 PM

comment #8

Gordon27 says ...

You know what we need, is more movies about the 1960's. How has cinema managed to completely ignore that decade despite how self-important the people who lived through it are?

Posted by Gordon27 at May 15, 2009 4:06 PM

comment #9

MilkMan says ...

This movies looks like something that would've starred Henry Winkler back in 1979. So far, I cannot stand the people who think Demetri Martin is funny. I saw his show. Put me to sleep. He reminds me of a kindergarten teacher we used to have who died of leukemia at age 37.

Posted by MilkMan at May 15, 2009 4:38 PM

comment #10

actionman says ...

Who the F is Demetri Martin?

Posted by actionman at May 15, 2009 4:47 PM

comment #11

MilkMan says ...

no one, actionman. just the latest pretender to the throne.

Posted by MilkMan at May 15, 2009 4:57 PM

comment #12

mccool says ...

A think a more interesting study would be Woodstock '94 and what transpired in the intervening 25 years that it made it so much the antithesis of the original. The unmitigated and completely hollow rage of the pampered slackers, the price-gouging, etc, etc ... or was that the 99 one? I cant remember

Posted by mccool at May 15, 2009 6:10 PM

comment #13

mccool says ...

'99....so the intervening 30 year period...

Posted by mccool at May 15, 2009 6:12 PM

comment #14

Baron Munchausen-by-Proxy says ...

JW, it was the *rumor* before the festival that it was 'free' that led to the over-traffic and those fences coming down. After the concert commenced and crowds were still showing up, Lang capitulated and it was officially free.

Not that that makes this Boomer fapfap any more enticing.

Posted by Baron Munchausen-by-Proxy at May 15, 2009 9:16 PM

comment #15

p.Vice says ...

Hm, a shitty Ang Lee movie? Never could have seen that coming.

Posted by p.Vice at May 15, 2009 10:52 PM

comment #16

BurmaShave says ...

Seriously, from the moment the poster and the trailer hit, did this look good to anyone?

Posted by BurmaShave at May 15, 2009 10:53 PM

comment #17

Ryansi51 says ...

yeah, a lot of people on here for some crazy reason. i got shit for saying it looked lame.

Posted by Ryansi51 at May 16, 2009 11:41 AM

comment #18

jimb12345 says ...

woodstock was such a crazy time. This was a good movie but unsure about it. I think it could have been better.

Adapter

Posted by jimb12345 at October 6, 2009 8:36 PM

comment #19

funlol says ...

Yikes. Wasn't expecting this review from you, Wells. Sounds very "mezzo-mezzo," to borrow one of your best catch-phrases.
auto insurance for young drivers

Posted by funlol at October 22, 2009 8:53 AM

comment #20

free games says ...

Too bad. I had high hopes for this film.

Posted by free games at October 26, 2009 10:20 AM

comment #21

AaronK says ...

Too bad. I had high hopes for this film. Ang Lee is greatness!
Лучшие проститутки - дешевые
проститутки.

Posted by AaronK at March 4, 2010 8:53 AM

comment #22

jimb12345 says ...

this movie was so good to me. It was good from beginning to end.
jacksonville beach dentist

Posted by jimb12345 at March 6, 2010 12:47 PM

comment #23

jimb12345 says ...

this movie was so good to me. It was good from beginning to end.
jacksonville beach dentist

Posted by jimb12345 at March 6, 2010 12:47 PM

comment #24

marklesner says ...

Thanks for sharing this.
Degree essay | Demonstrative Essays | Descriptive Essays | Essay formats | Essay Help

Posted by marklesner at March 10, 2010 2:44 AM

comment #25

doublexjohn says ...

Thanks for sharing the information. That's a awesome article you posted. I will come back to read some more. There are also lots of information about
credit protection service

Posted by doublexjohn at April 27, 2010 8:50 PM

comment #26

doublexjohn says ...

Would you have said the same thing, had the lead been heterosexual? Le Corbusier Sofa

Posted by doublexjohn at April 29, 2010 9:06 AM

comment #27

johnybaba says ...

Posted by johnybaba at May 12, 2010 12:22 AM

comment #28

emogurl12 says ...

Can there be a way to eliminate that online system? I'm receiving a large amount of mails. online fax

Posted by emogurl12 at May 16, 2010 8:43 AM

comment #29

sexy12 says ...

Thanks for sharing the information dude. I found the information very helpful. That's a awesome article you posted. I will come back to read some more. id theft help

Posted by sexy12 at May 22, 2010 10:27 PM

comment #30

sexy12 says ...

But the real reason LIVE FREE doesn't count is Willis is completely bald and doesn't smoke, hence ZERO CONTINUITY with 1-3. And I like Wiseman fine but you could tell he just wanted to cut loose with his ice-cold, super-blue monochrome vampire sheen, but had to half-ass it with all those nods to DIE HARD YELLOW, not to mention any movie from Fox has to look as yellow and urine-tinted as a butterscotch candy.

pwned tshirts

Posted by sexy12 at May 23, 2010 12:19 AM

comment #31

pooh12 says ...

AJ Schnack is an independent filmmaker. He directed Kurt Cobain: About a Son, which premiered at the 2006 Toronto International Film Festival.Social Bookmarking

Posted by pooh12 at May 29, 2010 10:52 AM

comment #32

jack444 says ...

Yeah, I know it's a broken record with me, but this looks like yet another great movie that nobody outside of NY and LA will see because SPC will slow and tightfisted with the rollout. online fax

Posted by jack444 at May 31, 2010 8:36 AM

comment #33

crazzyy44 says ...

Posted by crazzyy44 at June 7, 2010 8:38 AM

comment #34

ap222 says ...

A generation began in his backyard. From Academy Award-winning director Ang Lee (Brokeback Mountain, Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon), comes Taking Woodstock, a new comedy inspired by the true..
Cricut cartridges

Posted by ap222 at July 3, 2010 6:19 AM

comment #35

juicy couture says ...

you really have avery nice article,it's the first time to be here but it won't be the last untill then keep update..goodluck!

Posted by juicy couture at July 18, 2010 7:07 PM

comment #36

lose weight at home says ...

at home workouts
abs workout at home
chest workout at home
how to exercise at home
how to lose weight at home
medicine ball abs
upper body workout at home

Learn a few get your body in shape with these exercise routines at home and also get rid of your dandruff through the use of
dandruff home remedy to get the perfect body

Posted by lose weight at home at July 24, 2010 2:03 PM

comment #37

wookie21 says ...

Leicester Bank l Loans Unsecured Bad Credit l Loans Guarantor l Loan Hsbc l Loan Natwest l Personal Unsecured Loans Bad Credit l Loans Sainsburys l Loans Aa l Loans Asda l Loans Egg l Loans Abbey l Alliance Loan l Unsecured Loans Guaranteed l Loans Very Bad Credit

Posted by wookie21 at September 9, 2010 5:59 AM

comment #38

Sharay Narayana says ...

Woodstock is well known music festival where many rock band and singer perform altogether.
netload search | travel destinations | Philippine real estate

Posted by Sharay Narayana at September 12, 2010 11:03 PM

comment #39

cricutcartridges says ...

Cricut Cartridges
New Cricut Cartridges
Used Cricut Cartridges
Cricut Cartridge

Posted by cricutcartridges at September 14, 2010 9:18 PM

comment #40

angelgreen says ...

1. On the most alluring quality of the sheepskin boot, is that you can wear them all year all. They keep your feet warm in winter and cool in summer. For those who desire for a black uggs, but have to refrain themselves from buying one due to financial constraints, there are some reputed black uggsselling company that offer cheap ugg boots for women, with a pair of fashionable and eye catching ugg boots for women, you can experience your confidence rising and admiration in the eyes of all onlookers.

Posted by angelgreen at September 17, 2010 7:49 PM

comment #41

wookie21 says ...

Asbestos Lawsuit
Tampa Criminal Attorney
Natwest Loans
Egg Loans
Alliance Leicester Bank
Name Badges

Posted by wookie21 at September 23, 2010 6:37 AM

comment #42

jordan heels says ...

Have you ever seen such fashion of air jordan heels? In comparison with sporadic release in last few years, this year is really good for Air Jordan lovers. We have informed jordan high heel boots of new released jordan heel boots autumn/winter collection 2010 to our customer. Luckily, we have get large inquires on it. We are so glad to hear from all over the world.

Posted by jordan heels at November 5, 2010 7:42 PM

comment #43

Boots Uggs says ...

Its so interesting.Boots Uggs Its a very useful article.Boots Uggs I like the way you explain the things.This is a high quality posting.Keep do it. Thanks!

Posted by Boots Uggs at November 29, 2010 11:04 PM

comment #44

jordanheel says ...

You write a good article, I thank you can share with me.

Posted by jordanheel at December 7, 2010 7:17 PM

comment #45

jordanheel says ...

Thank you for posting this,jordan heels
jordan high heels
jordan high heel boots
jordan heels
jordan high heels
jordan high heels boots
jordan heel boots
jordan high heel shoes
jordan heels for womens jordan heels shoes
jordan heels boots
high heel jordans
jordan high heels for women
women jordan high heels
women jordan heels womens jordan heels
air jordan heels
air jordan high heels
nike air jordan heels
air jordan high heel boots
nike jordan heels
it was quite handy and told a lot

Posted by jordanheel at December 7, 2010 9:52 PM

comment #46

lucine says ...

Uggs Boots
Grey Uggs
leather ugg boots
leather ugg
ugg usa
australian ugg boots
uggs browns
ugg boots for women
black uggs
ugg usa

Posted by lucine at December 9, 2010 10:10 PM

comment #47

rosetta says ...

Its so interesting. Its a very useful article. I like the way you explain the things.rosetta edition
learning with rosetta
rosetta diskThis is a high quality posting.Keep do it. Thanks!

Posted by rosetta at February 9, 2011 10:59 PM

comment #48

Gucci Outlet o says ...

Very happy to share this website, which product genuine goods at reasonable prices, the style be also the most popular this year

Posted by Gucci Outlet o at April 18, 2011 7:12 PM

comment #49

kramnella says ...

Cool Article! Keep it up man!
vacation deals

Posted by kramnella at June 21, 2011 11:35 PM

comment #50

Jay Smith says ...

A generation began in his backyard. From Academy Award-winning director Ang Lee (Brokeback Mountain, Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon), comes Taking Woodstock, a new comedy inspired by the true.

Posted by Jay Smith at October 26, 2011 12:08 PM

comment #51

Jay Smith says ...

Yeah, I know it's a broken record with me, but this looks like yet another great movie that nobody outside of NY and LA will see because SPC will slow and tightfisted with the rollout.

asbestos lawyer

mesothelioma lawyer

Weight Loss Tips

Posted by Jay Smith at October 26, 2011 12:09 PM

comment #52