Boilerplate Best Picture Default

The age-old Steven Spielberg = sweeping emotionality equation had led five Gold Derby experts — Hollywood Reporter‘s Scott Feinberg, Village Voice‘s Michael Musto, Movieline‘s Stu Van Airsdale plus Gold Derby‘s Tom O’Neil and Paul Sheehan — to forecast a War Horse Best Picture win. Five others have picked The Descendants, and two have gone for The Artist. I’m the only Moneyball guy, and Rolling Stone‘s Peter Travers is picking The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo.

13 thoughts on “Boilerplate Best Picture Default

  1. Everyone seems to be betting on the come, looking for movies to break through in the last 3 months of the year that will define the BP race. I agree with them based on history and also based on the films released so far this year – I doubt if more than one or two of the movies we have already seen will be in the BP discussion in January; my money is on Tree of Life and Midnight in Paris.

    Second thought (tied to the first): I am glad to see that The Help is slipping down the rankings after all the ridiculous hype of August, though I am not surprised it is viewed more favorably by the panel than Moneyball. But I don’t see either of these making the BP race unless there is a real collapse in all of the anticipated films coming out in the next 3 months.

  2. The War Horse trailer looked promising, although i’m concerned that the screenplay is by Richard Curtis… that could bring out the worst in Spielberg.

  3. If they do ten nominations again, here’s how I think it’d go. — 10 is what I think should be nominated

    1. moneyball

    2. warhorse

    3. the descendants

    4. the help

    5. midnight in paris

    6. tinker, tailor, solider, spy

    7. tree of life

    8. the girl with the dragon tattoo

    9. rise of the planet of the apes

    10. *Warrior*

  4. Its been said a million times- who CARES what the Best Picture NOMINEES are, there are TEN of them.

    There aren’t ten worthy nominees in any year. OF COURSE Moneyball will be part of that group.

    I don’t think it wins- as JR mentioned, it’s TOO EARLY- but of course it gets nominated.

    YOU CAN NOMINATE TEN MOVIES!!

    Dumbest rule change ever.

  5. Ray, with the changes for this year, only 5 are guaranteed to be in the race, max up to 10. I will be surprised if more than 6 or 7 films make it into the race under the new rules (as I understand it, a film has to get 5% of the first place votes on all ballots to be included in the BP race).

    Hence all the discussion about films on the bubble.

  6. The War Horse trailer looked promising, although i’m concerned that the screenplay is by Richard Curtis… that could bring out the worst in Spielberg.

  7. This early in the race, they’re bowing to prestige. Remember when Charlie Wilson’s War was at the head of these lists in 2007?

    Spielberg’s won two Best Director Oscars, and neither of them were for his more sentimental stuff. War Horse could break out and be appealing to Oscar voters in just the way Dreamworks hopes it will, or it will fall victim to soft reviews and a ‘been-there done-that’ feel.

    On the other hand, if Sideways had George Clooney-level star power, it probably would have had a good chance at winning in 2004.

    Seeing Moneyball tonight, hope its as good as Jeff is saying, but my feelings on The Social Network were mixed. That said, Moneyball doesn’t look like it will be blatantly indignant toward an entire generation.

    Jus’ my 2 cents.

  8. Some great places to buy these replica watches australia are online web portals where you can get good deals on these Watches. The price usually ranges from $80 and can go as high as $300 depending on the Omega model that you are choosing. There are also many sites that offer these Replica Watches at a much lesser price but beware of their inferior quality. They might not work after you have in on your wrist after all. The best thing is that you just place an order and it gets delivered to where ever you want and free of cost.Expect matching the real prices, the cartier replica watches match the original looks and excellence very much .Also, they are the high quality Watches. For the Replicas are made to such perfection that you will fail to find the same thing between the real one. So this option can be light on your pocket but at the same time make you proud to wear a brand which most people only dream of wearing. These Watches are available even via online shopping and can work as a perfect and most awaited gift for your near and dear ones.Omega is one of the biggest brands in the world of Watches. People desire to own an Omega Watch simply because of its much-coveted brand name if not also because of its high quality and incomparable looks. Wearing a Omega is like a status symbol for many while others only get to see it and crave to own one.Patek 5107 platine Patek 4906/101 or blanc

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>