Holding On

I’ve been reading Phillip Roth‘s books all my life. It was his compulsive candor about sex, I think, that hooked me initially and kept me coming back. For some reason I was more impressed by Roth’s stories about horndog behavior than I was by, say, Henry Miller‘s. Roth was the first guy I read who described anal. That got to me on a certain level. I said to myself, “Well, if Phillip Roth can not only go there but openly write about it, I guess it’s an okay thing.”

These days Roth is writing about the approaching finale, about humbling, about everyone dying around him. I guess this is why he’s let himself be profiled by an American Masters doc. He’s figuring it’s now or never. He’ll turn 80 on 3.19.

I have to be honest — I’ve only seen half of Philip Roth: Unmasked. I was enjoying it but I was tired or something. It’s a 90-minute portrait in which Roth riffs on his life and art “as he has never done before,” the copy says. It debuts on PBS on 3.29, but on Wednesday it’ll play at the Film Forum for a week.

I’ve read Portnoy’s Complaint, Our Gang, The Human Stain, The Ghost Writer (’79), The Dying Animal, a screenplay based on American Pastoral but not the book, Goodbye Columbus, Zuckerman Unbound (’81). Now that I’ve been somewhat re-energized I’d like to read The Anatomy Lesson (’83), The Prague Orgy (’85), all of I Married A Communist (’98, having read about a third of it) and Exit Ghost (’07).

“The crux of this plainly observed and illuminating documentary, centered on filmed interviews with the novelist that are organized into a loose biographical portrait, is a classic story of personal and artistic self-discovery,” New Yorker critic Richard Brody writes. “[This began] with the thirtyish writer’s recognition, nearly half a century ago, in the company of a new group of like-minded friends in New York, that his round-table comedic voice was entertaining and therefore needed to be channelled into his work.

“The result, of course, was Portnoy’s Complaint, one of the key literary works of the sixties, which also made Roth famous. In much of the discussion that follows, he explains how he dealt with his new public persona — and how he transformed his experiences into fiction.

“His achievements are parsed and praised in interviews with such writers as Nicole Krauss, Jonathan Franzen and Claudia Roth Pierpont. Along the way, it’s as if yet another voice, another mask, were under construction: that of the wise retiree, facing the end of his life with a jovially sardonic serenity, if for no other reason than the confidence that his written voice will outlive him.”

  • http://www.stlcardinalbaseball.com/ Ray DeRousse

    That’s quite an opening paragraph, Jeffrey. Um … speechless.

    • Noiresque

      Proving those wrong who say that images of sex in the mass media have no effect on behaviour!

  • Noiresque

    Somewhat pettily, I hope he does not become the next Nobel laureate from the USA – since Updike carked it, I’m holding out for Pynchon, DeLillo, Russo or a playwright.

    I’m somewhat pleased he has retired. I can only take write-what-you-know so far when another book about the aging, academic sexual beast falls from his pen.

    • Max Stephens

      Elmore Leonard for Nobel.

      • Noiresque

        Works for me.

  • George Prager

    He’s awesome. I’ve read all of his novels, even “The Great American Novel.” Not sure where Noiresque gets the “aging academic” thing from. It’s like saying Scorcese only makes gangster movies.

  • George Prager

    He probably retired because he remembers telling a dying Bernard Malamud that his last finished novel, “God’s Grace”, wasn’t any good and that he shouldn’t publish it. maybe he doesn’t want to put someone else in the same awkward position.

  • Raising_Kaned

    The first paragraph is actually quite telling as to why Jeff could never quite manage to fully distance himself from Lex on this site (i.e. continuing to quote him in blog entries even after he had been “banned” for the third time, etc.).

  • http://twitter.com/jessecrall Jesse Crall

    His last book, Nemesis, was a solid finale. A little slight but certainly the work of someone going out with his full grasp of skills. Prager’s probably right re the Malamud bit; Roth’s a proud guy and I imagine the thought of slowing down or slipping churns his stomach.

    Roth is one of my faves because he managed to marry high art with entertainment. The little DeLillo I’ve read was easy to write essays on but didn’t suck me in like, say, American Pastoral.

    • George Prager

      DeLillo’s Underworld was a huge disappointment for me. I loved Libra and White Noise.

      • http://www.facebook.com/jesse.crall.3 Jesse Crall

        The 1st 70 pages of Underworld with the Thompson home run ball were fantastic. The next…800 lost me.

        • http://twitter.com/Glenn__Kenny Glenn Kenny

          I think you’re going to lose Jeff on DeLillo. Not enough anal sex.

          • http://twitter.com/phimseto Paul Marzagalli

            Have you read Cosmopolis? Asymmetrical prostates all over the place. Might do the trick.

  • Marty Melville

    Writing a review of Lehman’s atrocious adaptation of Portnoy’s Complaint prompted me to jump back into Roth and I landed on Sabbath’s Theater. A great, great book.

    • George Prager

      Yes, Sabbath’s Theater!

      • http://twitter.com/Biffwilcox BiffWilcox

        I’ve loved every other Roth book I’ve read, especially American Pastoral, but I could not get through Sabbath’s Theatre. I hardly ever discard books halfway through but I couldn’t put that one down fast enough. I’m not entirely sure why either.

  • George Prager

    ” Now that I’ve been somewhat re-energized I’d like to read The Anatomy Lesson (’83),The Prague Orgy (’85), all of I Married A Communist (’98, having read about a third of it) and Exit Ghost (’07).”

    All good except Exit Ghost. Might I recommend The Counterlife, My Life As a Man, The Professor of Desire, Letting Go, and Sabbath’s Theater? And then you have When She Was Good, which doesn’t have one Jewish character in it.

  • George Prager

    Great Jewish novels (after you’ve read Roth):
    The Assistant – Malamud
    Seize the Day – Bellow
    Stern – Bruce Jay Friedman
    A New Life – Malamud
    Household Words – Joan Silber
    Passage from Home – Isaac Rosenfeld

    To an Early Grave – Wallace Markfield

  • http://twitter.com/jasctt Jason T.

    Give me Saul Bellow any day of the week. Different strokes and all that. And there’s nothing wrong with anyone taking stock of their lives. I was in a taxi the other morning with a 74 YEAR OLD driver who works four 12 shifts every week (down from 5 because he is going through chemo). When I reacted to this, he just said “I’ve done enough.” Perfect.

  • http://twitter.com/jasctt Jason T.

    Henry MIller’s best work has NOTHING to do with sex. That this is lost on Wells is pretty telling.

  • Max Stephens

    Support what Prager said. A New Life and, especially, Stern are great novels. I prefer Augie March and Henderson the Rain King for Bellow. Those who like Roth, Bellow, Cheever, or Updike would like A Fan’s Notes by Frederick Exley, the greatest American book about failure.

  • Bob Hightower

    Folks, you forget — Jeff IS Lex, and Lex IS Jeff.