“The Lewis Black of Oscar bloggers” —Patrick Goldstein, “The Big Picture”, L.A. Times

Concern over "Lambs"

Posted by Jeffrey Wells on September 02, 2007 at 08:28 AM

I need to put this the right way, which is to say not too definitively or emphatically. But over the last two days I've heard from two second-hand sources (one of them having direct access to someone close to the action) that there's concern -- a moderate term that doesn't mean panic or alarm -- about the emerging shape of Robert Redford's Lions for Lambs (MGM/United Artists, 11.9).


It's not so much advance-word terms like "dull" and "pedantic" -- there are always people with agendas who will tell you this or that film isn't working, particularly around this time of year -- as much as a report that "an editing team has been brought in to fix it." One of the editors is long-time veteran Paul Hirsch (Ray, Mission: Impossible, The Empire Strikes Back).

Redford is known to be exacting and methodical (polite terms for "slow") in the cutting room, and he's been working with highly respected editor Joe Hutshing (who won Best Editing Oscars for Born on the Fourth of July and JFK) so there's no reason to think anything might be amiss in the skill and vision departments.

If the "fix-it" editing team info is true (I trust the source), the most likely scenario is that Cruise-Wagner and Redford are at odds over certain aspects of the film and that the UA chiefs have pulled rank. Redford is a tough hombre and doesn't back off (a key ingredient with any strong director), but Lions for Lambs is the first picture out of the gate from United Artists and there's a lot riding on it, especially with the heat on Cruise (who plays a right-wing Senator in Lambs) having dimin- ished over the last couple of years.

This doesn't mean, of course, that things won't pan out in the end. Disagreements about final refinements to a film are part of the natural creative fiction, and there's no question that Cruise, Wagner and Redford are smart, shrewd players who know from quality.

I've never read Matthew Michael Carnahan's script -- an apparently Babel-like piece about a California professor (Redford) and his influence over two students (Derek Luke, Michael Pena) and how their fates (as well as a third Redford student, played by Andrew Garfield) are affected in some way by a "bombshell story" given by a high-powered Senator (Cruise) to a seasoned Washington, D.C., journalist (Meryl Streep) -- but it's hard to imagine it not being an above-average work, given the pedigree of the players.

Lions for Lambs is going to play the AFI Film Festival on 11.1.

Comments

i have a feeling this movie is going to be terrific. not sure what exactly...i haven't read the script, though after seeing The Kingdom, another film written by Matthew Michael Carnahan, I am certainly anxious to see more of his work. Redford can be a great director when he wants too, and as you say, there is a lot of pedigree.

But you can't cut around the sets, the wardrobe and the hair. Where's that trailer?

My understanding was that the budget for this thing was fairly low (mid-30's). If that's correct, then the issue can't be about the financial return. Also, doesn't Redford have final cut?

I seriously can't stand that poster with Redford's digitally smoothed over face.

Final cut just means you can never be shown the door, it doesn't preclude everything written in Wells' post.

Remember kiddos: Every oak tree was once an acorn.

I admire Redford and have liked some of his directing efforts, but this trailer gave me a bad feeling. This could be another "high-pedigree" catastrophe along the lines of "Breaking & Entering."

Is there no trailer in the US yet, T. Holly? I saw one in front of Bourne Ultimatum a couple of weeks ago. I'm in New Zealand. Surely one has been screened in the US by now.

I am disappointed in Redford's refusal to let himself age. Same thing for Warren Beatty, whom I also otherwise admire. Lose the silk screen. At least Beatty hasn't gone the surgery route, like Redford has. There is something so lovely about a real age face. Plastic surgery almost always looks awful.

Plastic surgery...god, did anyone else see Mary Matalin on MTP this morning? She's starting to make Carville look attractive.

As for LFL, I asked Cruise how it was cutting together while I was installing two-way mirrors at his pad in Brentwood, but all he wanted to do was audit me. Which he ain't gonna do.

I still have a lot of faith in the man who directed ORDINARY PEOPLE, A RIVER RUNS THROUGH IT and QUIZ SHOW. Has he ever really made a terrible film? THE LEGEND OF BAGGER VANCE is kind of overcooked, but I still think it's signifigantly underrated with some magical moments and a dynamite, albeit "magic negro", performance by Will Smith.

I'll go see this b/c of Streep, but the dialogue in the trailer has me fearing for the worst: sledgehammer politics a la Stanley Kramer. I hope these lines play better in context; otherwise, they'd sound phoney except on Bill Reilley's show.

I saw the trailer and pedantic is the word. Looks like a two-hour lecture. Years ago--decades ago--even when Redford got political, he was smart enough to make sure the film worked first. He seems to have lost that somewhere along the way.

"Has [Redford] ever really made a terrible film?"

Ladies and gentlemen, I give you... "The Milagro Beanfield War". There's a reason Chick Vennera (or whatever his name was) never had a career.

Oh man, I totally forgot about MILAGRO. Good call. Yeah.... yeesh.

What was the last hit that Redford was in?

This has bomb written all over it.

Post a Comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?



Last updated: October 3, 2007

                                       Obviously I'm light in several categories. 

                                      Suggestions and disputations are welcome.

 

BEST PICTUREAustralia (20th Century Fox), The Argentine (Focus Features), Guerilla (Focus Features), Milk (Focus Features), Seven Pounds (Sony), The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (Paramount/Warner Bros.), The Soloist (DreamWorks),  Body of Lies (Warner Bros.), Revolutionary Road (Paramount Vantage/DreamWorks), The Changeling (Universal Pictures),  Frost/Nixon (Universal), Doubt (Miramax), Blindness (Universal Pictures), Defiance (Paramount Vantage), The Duchess (Paramount Vantage), Valkyrie (MGM-UA), The Reader (Weinstein Co.)

BEST DIRECTOR: Fernando Meirelles (Blindness), David Fincher (The Curious Case of Benjamin Button), Ron Howard (Frost/Nixon), Brian Singer (Valkyrie), Baz Luhrmann (Australia), Steven Soderbergh (The Argentine and Guerilla), Gus Van Sant (Milk), Gabriele Muccino (Seven Pounds), Joe Wright (The Soloist), Ridley Scott (Body of Lies), Sam Mendes (Revolutionary Road), Clint Eastwood (Changeling), John Patrick Shanley (Doubt), Edward Zwick (Defiance), Saul Dibb (The Duchess), Stephen Daldry (The Reader)

BEST ACTOR: Leonardo DiCaprio (Revolutionary Road), Brad Pitt (The Curious Case of Benjamin Button), Ralph Fiennes (The Duchess), Hugh Jackman (Australia), Tom Cruise (Valkyrie), Harrison Ford (Crossing Over), Sean Penn (Milk), James Franco (Pineapple Express), Philip Seymour Hoffman (Synecdoche, New York), Heath Ledger (Dark Knight), Will Smith (Seven Pounds), Jamie Foxx (The Soloist)

BEST ACTRESS: Kate Winslet (Revolutionary Road), Angelina Jolie (Changeling), Keira Knightley (The Duchess), Nicole Kidman (Australia)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR: Leiv Schreiber (Defiance), Frank Langella (Frost/Nixon), John Malkovich (Changeling and Burn After Reading), Bill Nighy (Valkyrie), Robert Downey Jr. (The Soloist), Robert Downey Jr. (Tropic thunder), James Franco (The Pineapple Express), Alan Alda (Nothing But the Truth)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS: Meryl Streep (Doubt), Amy Adams (Doubt), Vera Farmiga (Nothing But the Truth)

BEST ANIMATED FEATURE: Dr. Seuss' Horton Hears a Who (20th Century Fox)

BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY: Charlie Kaufman (Synecdoche, New York)

BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY: Peter Straughan (How to Lose Friends and Alienate People)

SPECIAL EFFECTSIron Man, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull

 






Discland
edited by Jonathan Doyle
Cloverfield [BLU-RAY] (Paramount Home Entertainment, 6.3.2008) Disguised under deliberately goofy, yet deliciously edible-sounding, aliases such as Cheese and Slusho, Matt Reeves' Cloverfield was produced and rushed into theaters under an equally appetizing shroud of secrecy. From last year's incredibly elusive Super Bowl ad to the film's viral marketing campaign, Cloverfield had everybody scratching their heads and drooling in anticipation. Aside from the as-yet untitled title and the Blair Witch-ian visual style, the film's biggest appeal was the enigmatic creature who was last (un)seen hurling the decapitated head of the Statue of Liberty onto the crowded streets of New York City. All we knew about the mysterious beast was that it was big and angry. Now that the highy-anticipated project has come and gone, one question has fortunately been answered: Cloverfield was a major success. (continued)


American Express






Inside Elsewhere...

The Barenaked Critic

Michelle discovers a couple of comedy films thanks to the power of Netflix.

The Silver Spotlight

Adam joins the Elsewhere crew from the Windy City and hits the ground running this week.